Essay Upgrade

See exactly how to move from a Grade 8 to a Grade 9

Question: How does Priestley present responsibility in An Inspector Calls?
At this level, it's not about saying more - it's about saying things more precisely, thoughtfully and perceptively.
Original answer
A high-level response
Upgraded version
The same ideas - made sharper
What changed
The difference at top band
How to apply it
To reach Grade 9
📌 Even if this isn't your exact text, the same upgrade works for any question.
Before: Grade 8-style answer

Priestley presents responsibility through the contrast between the older and younger generations. Characters like Sheila and Eric are willing to accept blame, while Mr and Mrs Birling refuse to take responsibility for their actions. This shows a clear divide in attitudes and suggests that younger people are more willing to change.

This is shown when Sheila says "I know I'm to blame -- and I'm desperately sorry". The adverb "desperately" shows how strongly she feels and suggests her guilt is genuine. Priestley presents Sheila as someone who learns from her mistakes, which makes her seem more morally aware than her parents.

Priestley also uses the Inspector to present his views about responsibility. The Inspector argues that people should care for one another and that everyone is connected. This shows that Priestley believes responsibility is important in creating a better society.

Overall, Priestley presents responsibility as something that the upper classes often avoid, but which is necessary for social change. Through the younger characters and the Inspector, he suggests that society can improve if people accept responsibility for the impact of their actions.

After: Upgraded Grade 9-style answer

Priestley presents responsibility as a moral obligation that exposes the values of each character, using the generational divide not simply to show contrast, but to suggest where the future of society lies. In the play, responsibility becomes a measure of both personal integrity and social awareness, separating those capable of change from those determined to protect their own status.

This is evident when Sheila admits, "I know I'm to blame -- and I'm desperately sorry". The adverb "desperately" conveys genuine emotional urgency, but more importantly signals a shift in her self-awareness. Priestley presents responsibility here as something that must be recognised internally rather than imposed externally, suggesting that meaningful change depends on reflection, not just punishment.

In contrast, Mr Birling's refusal to accept responsibility is not simply stubbornness, but a reinforcement of capitalist self-interest. His concern for reputation over morality reveals how those in power can distance themselves from the consequences of their actions. The generational divide therefore becomes symbolic, representing a choice between preserving harmful systems and challenging them.

Furthermore, the Inspector functions as more than a moral voice. He can also be seen as a structural device used by Priestley to control the direction of the play and force both characters and audience to confront uncomfortable truths. This makes responsibility feel inescapable, as though the play itself insists that avoiding accountability leads only to repetition and further damage.

Ultimately, Priestley presents responsibility as central to creating a fairer society, but he also suggests that it requires both self-awareness and collective change. The play therefore acts not just as a warning, but as a deliberate call to action.

Why the first version stays around Grade 8
  • It is clear, developed and accurate
  • It uses relevant evidence and method analysis
  • The ideas are strong, but slightly expected rather than exploratory
  • It focuses more on the message than on how Priestley constructs meaning
  • The interpretation is good, but not yet as precise or evaluative as top band
What lifts it towards Grade 9
  • Makes the interpretation more precise and nuanced
  • Shifts from what happens to why Priestley presents it that way
  • Treats characters and structure as deliberate vehicles for ideas
  • Explores the Inspector as a structural device, not just a character
  • The whole argument feels more controlled, thoughtful and perceptive
What examiners are rewarding here
AO1 A more precise, conceptual and evaluative argument about responsibility
AO2 Analysis that focuses on meaning and writer's purpose, not just spotting techniques
AO3 Sharper understanding of Priestley's socialist message and criticism of power and class
Examiner move The upgraded answer feels deliberate, nuanced and fully controlled -- not just strong
Final step to Grade 9
1. Make your interpretation more precise
2. Focus on writer's intention as well as meaning
3. Treat structure and characters as deliberate choices
4. Keep the whole argument controlled and purposeful
More Essay Upgrades